The Xiaomi Mi MIX 2S Review: Fantastic Overall Value
by Andrei Frumusanu on June 29, 2018 8:00 AM EST- Posted in
- Mobile
- Smartphones
- Xiaomi
- MI MIX 2S
Camera - Low Light Evaluation
Moving on to low-light shots of the MIX 2S. The 1.4µm pixel pitch of the sensor along with the F/1.8 lens should give respectable results, although I’m not expecting it to beat the competition as it its optics are simply at a disadvantage in terms of raw technical specifications for low-light capture.
[ Mi MIX 2S ]
[ P20 Pro ] - [ P20 ] - [ P10 ]
[ Galaxy S9+ ] - [ iPhone X ] - [ Pixel 2 XL ]
Xiaomi’s tendency to oversaturate the scene takes on a funky result here as the MIX 2S is really bringing out the colours, especially on the blue sky in this after-sunset picture. The picture’s highlights are brought out too much as objects are too bright, but it’s still a good result. Xiaomi is lacking natural dynamic range here and thus the shadows are too dark, having too little light capture.
Although the MIX 2S produces a noisy picture, this actually helps it as it avoids the smudged textures that we see on the S9. Overall it’s still a good result, and it depends on preference on what you like more.
[ Mi MIX 2S ]
[ P20 Pro ] - [ P20 ] - [ P10 ] - [ Mate 10 Pro ]
[ Galaxy S9+ ] - [ iPhone X ] - [ Pixel 2 XL ]
In this shot Xiaomi surprisingly managed to produce a better dynamic range than the competition – bar the P20 Pro in 10MP mode which just has much better shadows. The S9 shot ended up oddly out of focus, so it’s not a valid comparison.
Detail wise the MIX 2S also actually wins out over Huawei and Apple, producing an excellent shot.
[ Mi MIX 2S ]
[ P20 Pro ] - [ P20 ] - [ P10 ] - [ Mate 10 Pro ]
[ Galaxy S9+ ] - [ iPhone X ] - [ Pixel 2 XL ]
Here the MIX 2S does really well in exposure, and beats the iPhone X and Pixel 2 XL in dynamic range. Colour reproduction seems also to be very good – something the S9 struggled with as it produces a far too warm result for the white lighting.
Detail wise the MIX 2S also beats the iPhone and Pixel, but the S9 just has more light capture to work with and does better on the textures and has more contrast. Obviously the P20 Pro wins out in the 10MP mode, as even though it’s a lower resolution image, the dynamic range advantage through the superior light capture is plainly obvious.
Extreme low light photography
[ Mi MIX 2S ]
[ P20 Pro ] - [ P20 ]
[ P10 ] - [ Mate 10 Pro ]
[ Galaxy S9+ ] - [ iPhone X ] - [ Pixel 2 XL ]
In extreme low-light environments the MIX 2S doesn’t have any special capture mode, and the resulting picture remains at a similar quality level as say, an iPhone X.
Overall the MIX 2S did not disappoint in terms of low-light capture. Its tendency to not apply too much noise reduction seems to come at an advantage for the camera as it avoids smudging out textures, resulting in more retained raw detail, although again, it’s noisy. Competitively it seems like a better low-light camera than the iPhone X and the Pixel 2’s. It’s trailing the Galaxy S9, but that was to be expected given the aperture disadvantage. While the MIX 2S beats the P20’s from Huawei in medium light in terms of details – at a certain point in sufficient low light, the P20 Pro’s vast light capture advantage turns the tide and maintains the current quality crown in terms of quality.
61 Comments
View All Comments
nathanddrews - Friday, June 29, 2018 - link
Definitely seems like a great value, but I know I couldn't buy it without an OLED screen. How close to a stock experience does MIUI 9 provide? It doesn't look very intrusive at all, I like it.Andrei Frumusanu - Friday, June 29, 2018 - link
I'll be adding a software section in a short while - I've had zero issues with MIUI 9.5. Xiaomi also offers quite a novel gesture navigation method that works really well and gets rid of the navigation bar creating more screen real estate.Flunk - Friday, June 29, 2018 - link
It's not that novel, OnePlus offers a similar feature.close - Saturday, June 30, 2018 - link
Yeah, BlackBerry really used gestures a lot since the beginning of this decade, Apple took them and made them famous with the iPhone X, but now they are no longer novel because OnePlus/Android also copied them in 2018? :)arashi - Sunday, July 1, 2018 - link
You mean Nokia? With the N9?arashi - Sunday, July 1, 2018 - link
*that pioneered extensive gesture navigationSamus - Sunday, July 1, 2018 - link
Palm beat virtually everyone by a number of years to the gesture game. Give credit where credit is due. WebOS revolutionized mobile OS navigation and virtually every OS since had borrowed almost everything from multitasking cards to an information "hub" from WebOS.On top of all that, Palm beat Apple to wireless charging by an entire DECADE (unless you consider the Apple Watch, which by that means Palm beat them by 'just' 7 years.) Palm's wireless charging implementation was also significantly better than Qi from more efficient charging current (excluding Qualcomm high voltage fast charging) to magnetic alignment.
Lord of the Bored - Sunday, July 1, 2018 - link
But if we give credit where it is due, we can't give credit to Apple instead!piroroadkill - Monday, July 2, 2018 - link
It's actually kind of depressing to anyone who owned a Palm device with wireless charging how shoddy current wireless technologies are, and how few devices actually support it. The Pre and the Touchpad charged without any hassle whatsoever.hbsource - Monday, July 2, 2018 - link
Well, kind of.The little stand for the Pre was great but my screen always remained powered up while charging. The screen would be dark and blank but that was still more than enough to illuminate a dark bedroom.
The OS was very good but the hardware was definitely shonky. My keyboard rubber literally wore through to the metal below and I had a couple of incidents where I lost all the stored data and photos.
Could have been great but wasn't quite.