Intel’s 11th Gen Core Tiger Lake SoC Detailed: SuperFin, Willow Cove and Xe-LPby Dr. Ian Cutress on August 13, 2020 9:01 AM EST
- Posted in
- Tiger Lake
- Willow Cove
- Intel Arch Day 2020
At the start of the year, Intel ‘foolishly’ handed me a wafer of its next generation Tiger Lake processors, as the moment it came into my hands I attempted to make a very quick exit. In my time with the wafer, we learned that this new 10nm laptop-focused processor had four cores, used Intel’s next generation Xe graphics architecture, and would set the stage at the end of the year as the cornerstone of Intel’s mobile processor offerings. As part of Intel’s Architecture Day 2020 a couple of days ago, the company went into detail about what makes Tiger Lake the true vehicle for 10nm, and why customers will want a Tiger Lake device.
Intel Architecture Day 2020, August 11th
Before we start into the information about Tiger Lake, I want to start by saying that the information in this article, as well as our coverage on Xe graphics and a number of upcoming mini-stories, all stems from Intel’s Architecture Day 2020 event. Building upon the success of the event in 2018, press and enthusiasts alike have continually asked when Intel would be doing it again. No doubt trying to pin down 20+ senior engineers and executives for an event at the same time in the same location is tough, and due to COVID this event was delayed at least twice.
Despite this, Intel made Arch Day 2020 a virtual event, allowing the engineers to pre-record their segments. The event was held behind closed doors, as with the 2018 event, the embargo lift was set for 1-2 days after. As a result, the articles you see published today are at the end of a lack of sleep between the event and now, as Intel went very dense very quickly (that’s a good thing™). We’ve digested as much as we can in that short space of time, we’ve asked some initial questions, but no doubt more will be asked as further analysis occurs.
The event was headlined by an effervescent Raja Koduri, who took the role of covering roadmaps and some of the Xe structural details. Prominent Intel Fellows and Engineers were the stars of the show in my eyes, particularly Ruth Brain (transistors), Ramune Nagisetty (packaging), Boyd Phelps (Tiger Lake), David Blythe (Xe GPU), Lisa Pierce (GPU software), Sailesh Kottapalli (Xeon) and others, all covering aspects of Intel’s strategy and portfolio.
Along with this article today covering Tiger Lake, we have an article going into the Xe graphics disclosures today as well. There are a number of mini-highlights from the event I also want to cover, and these will be published over the next few days.
Intel’s 11th Gen Core Tiger Lake SoC Detailed: Willow Cove and Xe-LP
Timeline: Tiger Lake will be Intel’s 11th Gen Core
Intel first unveiled its Core microarchitecture in Q1 2006, as an offshoot of the more power efficient Pentium Pro products. This was decided because the leading edge Intel products of the day, based on Netburst, were fast but hot and power hungry. By going down the route of Core, starting with Conroe, Intel has delivered multiple generations of products with the goal at each step to improve performance, power efficiency, and introduce better ways to perform compute.
|Intel's Core Family|
|1st Gen Core||2006||65nm||Conroe||-||Core 2|
|2nd Gen Core||2011||32nm||Sandy Bridge||Gen6||Sandy Bridge|
|3rd Gen Core||2012||22nm||Ivy Bridge||Gen7||Ivy Bridge|
|4th Gen Core||2013||22nm||Haswell||Gen7.5||Haswell|
|5th Gen Core||2015||14nm||Broadwell||Gen8||Broadwell|
|6th Gen Core||2015||14nm||Skylake||Gen9||Skylake|
|7th Gen Core||2017||14+||Kaby Lake||Gen9 LP||Kaby Lake|
|8th Gen Core||2017||14++||Coffee Lake||Gen9 LP||Coffee Lake|
|2017||10 minus||Palm Cove||Gen10*||Cannon Lake|
|2018||14++||Whiskey Lake||Gen9 LP||Whiskey Lake|
|2019||14+||Amber Lake||Gen9 LP||Amber Lake|
|9th Gen Core||2018||14++||Coffee Lake||Gen9 LP||Coffee Lake-R|
|10th Gen Core||2019||14+++||Comet Lake||Gen9||Comet Lake|
|2019||10nm||Sunny Cove||Gen11||Ice Lake|
|11th Gen Core||2020||10SF||Willow Cove||Xe-LP||Tiger Lake|
|*Cannon Lake's Gen10 was never enabled|
[table – year, generation, process node, core, soc]
Intel uses a lot of code names for its cores and for its products. The marketable names that get printed on the side of the retail box are do with ‘9th Generation Core’, however because we are dealing with the finer details of these products and cores, we prefer to use the code names. Keep this cheat sheet if the number of code names starts getting dense.
Tiger Lake pairs Willow Cove with Xe-LP
At its heart, the current Tiger Lake processor being presented by Intel is a four core mobile-series processor aimed at the 15 W target market where premium ultra-portable notebooks exist. Inside is four cores based on Intel’s Willow Cove architecture, the next generation after Sunny Cove, which we saw in Ice Lake. The four cores will be paired with 96 Execution Units of the new Xe-LP graphics architecture, and Tiger Lake will be Intel’s first product with Xe-LP.
Compared to Intel’s current generation product in this space, its Ice Lake processor, the number of CPU cores stays the same, but we move from a Sunny Cove core design to a Willow Cove core design, which has performance benefits we will detail later. Graphics is boosted in raw numbers by +50%, moving from 64 EUs to 96 EUs, however the architecture change from Ice Lake’s Gen11 design to the new Xe-LP affords additional performance benefits.
Tiger Lake also includes on-silicon support for technologies such as Thunderbolt 4, USB 4, PCIe 4.0, LPDDR5, as well as dedicated IP for total memory encryption and an updated Gaussian Neural Accelerator (to help with noise cancellation and similar functionality). We cover these on our page about Tiger Lake’s IO and sub-system.
No Longer on 10+, new 10nm SuperFin Technology
Tiger Lake uses Intel’s 10nm ‘SuperFin’ manufacturing process technology. As part of this launch, Intel has replaced the 10+ nomenclature and instead renamed it to 10nm SuperFin, or 10SF. This is in part due to some of the updates Intel has made to its 10nm process in order to enable some of the features in Tiger Lake.
The SuperFin technology includes a new high performance transistor methodology for the critical paths of Intel’s design, and an improved metal stack which uses novel materials in the latest update to Intel’s FinFET process technology. This includes evolutionary changes to achieve the required performance characteristics that perhaps should have been part of Intel’s 10nm process from the beginning.
We will also cover the new SuperFin over the course of our Intel Architecture Day coverage.
Intel has also renamed the generation after 10nm SuperFin, and called it 10nm Enhanced SuperFin, or 10ESF for short. This comes into play with some of Intel’s future products, such as its high performance computing GPU called Ponte Vecchio, as well as the next generation Xeon Scalable platform called Sapphire Rapids.
Tiger Lake Goals: Bigger and Better than Ice Lake
As part of Intel’s disclosures about Tiger Lake and specifically to talk on Willow Cove, Intel’s Boyd Phelps, the Tiger Lake SoC Lead Architect, spoke about how the new design, coupled with the new manufacturing technology, enables the new core to offer better performance and better performance efficiency at every point of the curve compared to Ice Lake.
As part of the design of Tiger Lake, Intel had two options on how to build on the Ice Lake design: push further with better single thread performance / IPC, or drive performance and efficiency. Intel ultimately focused more on the latter, as the engineers felt that it would enable a bigger leap in performance over the Ice Lake design.
This means that the new cores in Tiger Lake a built that for any given power or voltage, they will run at a higher frequency. Or for any given frequency, Tiger Lake will require a lower voltage. Where Ice Lake essentially topped out at 4.0 GHz within that 15 W window, Tiger Lake will start pushing numbers back up to 5.0 GHz.
This is important – when we reviewed Ice Lake, it was a bit of an odd situation. At the time, Intel’s main comparison point was its previous generation Whiskey Lake processors. Ice Lake afforded a raw 15-20% performance uplift against Whiskey Lake at the same frequency, which in general is a very good metric to have. However, Ice Lake was 10-20% lower on frequency, effectively nullifying all of those gains. At the same power, Ice Lake had a hard time beating the previous generation.
With Tiger Lake then, the stage seems to be set that the raw performance in frequency alone is going to jump anywhere from 10-20% depending on how the turbo modes are set to work in the final products. Intel puts this improvement in frequency down to its new SuperFin transistor design and updated manufacturing process.
When it comes to clock-for-clock raw performance gains for Tiger Lake, the differences compared to Ice Lake are not as clear cut, primarily because the cores microarchitecture layout between the two only has a few small changes. We’ll cover those a bit later.
Post Your CommentPlease log in or sign up to comment.
View All Comments
Mark242 - Thursday, August 13, 2020 - linkIs the SuperFin tech really a generational impovement of the 10nm process or is it a backport from 7nm?
Sahrin - Thursday, August 13, 2020 - linkSo basically Intel had to re-engineer the entire technology stack to get 10nm to work.
Are they still using EUV on all layers?
IanCutress - Thursday, August 13, 2020 - linkEUV for Intel is on 7nm. There's no EUV on 10 or 10SF.
trivik12 - Thursday, August 13, 2020 - linkDoes the comment that 10 SFE is optimized for DC and so Alderlake will not see any xtor improvements from TGL and its just microarchitecture changes to improve performance.
Thunder 57 - Thursday, August 13, 2020 - link"As for the L3 cache on a quad-core Willow Cove system, Intel has moved from an 8 MiB non-inclusive shared L3 cache to a 12 MiB shared L3 cache."
Pretty sure you meant inclusive L3, which the "Cache Comparison" chart got right.
WaltC - Thursday, August 13, 2020 - linkIan eating more silicon...ah...like a breath of fresh air...;) I find silicon wafers are best enjoyed with a set of Unobtanium™ dentures topped with the diamond tooth inserts and platinum alloy tips--chews up nice, goes down smooth! I have to agree in this really nice write up making the most of the sparseness Intel supplied, that all of this stuff looks incremental to me. Bits and pieces improved. Reading between the lines it looks like Intel is still struggling with its process nodes--the fact that they cannot ship even this right now is certainly telling...nor can they even supply a ship date, apparently.
Eliadbu - Thursday, August 13, 2020 - linkI sure hope to see TGL scaled to 8 cores CPUs. I feel like the biggest drawback of ICL is it was scaled up to 4 cores only making it underpowered to even comet lake u (with up to 6 cores).
harobikes333 - Saturday, August 15, 2020 - link"If you’ve skipped to the end of this article without reading the pages in between,...."
^ You caught me - I'm a sucker for summaries. If I have time, I go back & read through the full articles. Alas, there's only so much time in a day!
ksec - Saturday, August 15, 2020 - linkIn the previous driver update I was under the impression AV1 decode is only partly ASIC accelerated. But the slides here seems to imply it is fully Hardware Decoded.
Farfolomew - Saturday, August 15, 2020 - linkWhat's Intel playing at here with ignoring the 8-core offering of Renoir Mobile and just going for 4-core with Tiger Lake? This will be in effect for an entire generation (11th Gen) of mobile products, that they'll have a 50% core deficit. I get that Tiger Lake will have ~20% better ST performance over Renoir, and it could be argued that 4 cores is all one needs nowadays on Mobile, but still, it seems like a calculated and potentially dangerous move by Intel to ignore AMD's core-count advantage.